Pine Island, Bokeelia FL - Homes for Sale

13 homes for sale in Pine Island with an average listing price of $806,754 and an average size of 2,275 sqft.

4412 Pinetree BLVD St James City FL 33956

4412 Pinetree BLVD, St James City

$2,750,000 Single Family
MLS®: 2025009639 • Days Listed: 138
4 beds • 4 baths • 7500 sqFt
$ reduced from $3,000,000, 2026-01-12

8550 Ebbtide WAY Bokeelia FL 33922

8550 Ebbtide WAY, Bokeelia

$1,459,000 Single Family
MLS®: 2025001234 • Days Listed: 195
5 beds • 3 baths • 2245 sqFt
$ reduced from $1,469,000, 2026-02-02

4093 Sunshine BLVD St James City FL 33956

4093 Sunshine BLVD, St James City

$949,000 Single Family
MLS®: 2026002025 • Days Listed: 50
2 beds • 2 baths • 1300 sqFt

3128 Stringfellow RD St James City FL 33956

3128 Stringfellow RD, St James City

$799,000 Single Family
MLS®: 225039917 • Days Listed: 325
4 beds • 4 baths • 2362 sqFt
$ reduced from $804,000, 2026-03-09

12070 Bohman LN Bokeelia FL 33922

12070 Bohman LN, Bokeelia

$749,000 Single Family
MLS®: 2025025779 • Days Listed: 142
3 beds • 2 baths • 1688 sqFt
$ reduced from $774,000, 2026-05-13

2291 Palm AVE St James City FL 33956

2291 Palm AVE, St James City

$689,900 Single Family
MLS®: 2025019210 • Days Listed: 181
3 beds • 2 baths • 1707 sqFt
$ reduced from $699,900, 2025-12-30

5304 Ann Arbor DR Bokeelia FL 33922

5304 Ann Arbor DR, Bokeelia

$675,000 Single Family
MLS®: 2026004784 • Days Listed: 45
3 beds • 2 baths • 2527 sqFt
$ reduced from $700,000, 2026-02-24

6170 Stringfellow RD St James City FL 33956

6170 Stringfellow RD, St James City

$550,000 Single Family
MLS®: 2025008758 • Days Listed: 171
3 beds • 2 baths • 2237 sqFt
$ reduced from $575,000, 2026-02-20

3587 Myers LN St James City FL 33956

3587 Myers LN, St James City

$550,000 Single Family
MLS®: 225028509 • Days Listed: 300
4 beds • 3 baths • 2130 sqFt
$ reduced from $595,000, 2025-11-03

10925 Russell RD Bokeelia FL 33922

10925 Russell RD, Bokeelia

$335,000 Single Family
MLS®: 225014802 • Days Listed: 461
3 beds • 3 baths • 1601 sqFt
$ reduced from $345,000, 2025-12-17

15925 Quail TRL Bokeelia FL 33922

15925 Quail TRL, Bokeelia

$280,000 Single Family
MLS®: 224077294 • Days Listed: 500
2 beds • 1 baths • 860 sqFt
$ reduced from $285,000, 2026-02-11